Saturday, October 31, 2026

Another Man's Poison, Robbery, Murder, and Deceit

This one reminds me of those early Hammer films, before Hammer went into horror. You know those clever mysteries with heavy irony included. A cavernous mansion on the Yorkshire Moors is our setting, and yes there will be a dark and stormy night...should keep Snoopy happy. Murder? Yep...and don't hold your breath, more murder. In fact so many in this film just deserve killing...the question is, which ones will be slaughtered? Our feature today is 1951's "Another Man's Poison," directed by Irving Rapper.

Janet (Bette Davis) is a mystery novelist who is having an affair with her lovely secretary's (Barbara Murray) fiancé Larry (Anthony Steel). The secretary Chris doesn't know and either does Janet's husband. Actually, Janet murdered her husband earlier in the day. Why? He's a man! Probably had it coming. Being a mystery novelist, Janet has what it takes to get away with the perfect murder. Ha! We see where this is going. That would be true if the rest of the world cooperated. See, yesterday Janet's Husband robbed a bank with the ne'er-do-well George (Gary Merrill). Now when Janet arrives home, George is waiting for her husband. He claims the cop shot during the robbery was shot by her husband even though the cops blame him. George needs the husband to tell the cops he did not shoot anyone...then Janet gives him the bad news. Now George has something to hang over Janet and Janet has something to hang over George.

Solution? Bad one. No one knows what Janet's husband looks like. George figures on impersonating Janet's husband. Thus he can hide out and Janet's husband has an alibi. What could go wrong? You've had them...nosy neighbors...servants who know too much...houseguests who take more and more liberties. Janet and George plot...but their plans do not include each other. Janet has killed once and George has a gun. Together they both got rid of the husband's body...and now both realize how easy and nice life would be without the other one. Janet pulls some smart moves...then George reminds her which one is more psycho. A shout out to Dr. Henderson (Emlyn Williams) who is the nosy neighbor who asks so many questions that are none of his business...why? Uh oh...Dr. Henderson isn't the only one who knows more than he lets on.  Janet and George both figure the other needs killing...but each one has to be careful.

Will our evil mystery writer get away with murder?  Will our desperate bank robber play the wrong hand now that he is shacking up with a murderess? Just what does Dr. Henderson know and why hasn't he gone to the police?  This is a good one with a shocking ending. Well acted and reminiscent of a great stage play with an Agatha Christie flavor to it. See "Another Man's Poison" and see if everyone really does get what they deserve.

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Night Won't Talk, A Sultry Model Strangled

Sure, the night won't talk.  How about the chatty dames competing for modeling jobs. Can you picture them not talking? Or how about the ...